KonaKagmi was real

[Forsakn Wrath]

ive been wondering how people word react if Kagami Yoshimizu
announce that Konata and Kagami were in a love relationship.



this is just my interest. so i dont want a smarta** answer thy're not together get over it kinda of thing.

[Yoda]

Inevitable mass-fangasms.

EDIT: Might as well put my own opinions in as well. I'd be "meh". At least Konata won't breed (inb4testtubebaby) :P Shame about Kagami, though.

[veehive]

I would be hard-pressed to accept it based on the manga & anime having already established themselves as non-ecchi. It simply doesn't fit the style of the manga & show as already established. I would fear that Mr. Yoshimizu had given in to some wierd Commercial pressures or that he had lost his mind to alcohol or drugs.

And that is my reaction to your hypothetical scenario. No smart-alec implicit therein.

[Yoda]

I would be hard-pressed to accept it based on the manga & anime having already established themselves as non-ecchi. It simply doesn't fit the style of the manga & show as already established.
Hmm, yeah. I'd have to agree with this. Any relationship (hetero or not) just wouldn't be right for Lucky Star.

That said, however, I wouldn't mind if there was some sexual tension between them (one-sided would be interesting as well), as long as it's not overdone.

[Hiyori's-Boyfriend]

It would add an Intresting Plot Twist (Wait, Lucky star has a Plot?) and would alow for further character Development.

But, If it even was real. Would it stay a Serious topic, Or just turn into a eechi fest?

[furball]

I'd like it more. The world needs more comedic yuri.

[Supernova141]

Nothing would change. The show is still exactly the same, does the word of the person who made it really mean more than what's in the show itself?

Not like 90% of the fandom doesn't pretend it's real anyway...

[Lyricalias]

It would be pretty weird, since the show doesn't really suggest there's a relationship at all.

[Konata Izumi]

It would add an Intresting Plot Twist (Wait, Lucky star has a Plot?) and would alow for further character Development.

But, If it even was real. Would it stay a Serious topic, Or just turn into a eechi fest?


It would make be great for further character developement.(Actually, It would awesome and cute if it was put into the series, and I'm a strong KonaKaga fan myself.)

Whether it will be serious or an ecchi fest really depends on how Mr. Yoshimizu writes in the series.(But it will be nice if it was a little of both from time to time, depending on the situation of what Konata and Kagamin are doing.)

[Droote]

That would ruin the manga more or less as lots of jokes and scenarios happen because they are friends. Also, that would seem like, as veehive said, Yoshimizu had given in for the pressure of commercialisation. Someone could get a boyfriend/girlfriend, but if any of the characters would fell in love with each other, then LS would suck. The whole point about the whole thing is that they are friends.

[Haruka]

I would love it. Okay, thats easy for me, `cause i´m a KonaKaga-Fan^^.
Anyway, i think it would take Lucky Star to a higher Level, because Yuri and Comedy/Lice-of-Life is a perfect compination for entertaiment.
Lucky Star with KonaKaga would looking like this:
http://i847.photobucket.com/albums/ab38/HarukaShinigami/Lucky%20Star%20yonkoma/IWantToTryMakingYouCry.jpg?t=1278954692
or this:
http://i847.photobucket.com/albums/ab38/HarukaShinigami/Lucky%20Star%20yonkoma/YuriSpace-Time.jpg?t=1278954803

[Forsakn Wrath]

Someone could get a boyfriend/girlfriend, but if any of the characters would fell in love with each other, then LS would suck. The whole point about the whole thing is that they are friends.

So you dont mind romance or the fact they could be lesbians but you will deny any form of love between any two characters

they are still friends, just they love each other

[Yoda]

So you dont mind romance or the fact they could be lesbians but you will deny any form of love between any two characters

they are still friends, just they love each other
Lucky Star isn't about romance. 'Nuff said.

[Forsakn Wrath]

Lucky Star isn't about romance. 'Nuff said.

Droote add an opinion so im question it out of interest...Nuff said

[Yoda]

Droote add an option so im question it out of interest...Nuff said
This post is virtually unintelligible. Fact remains that Lucky Star doesn't focus on this stuff. It's a 4koma strip akin to stuff like Calvin and Hobbes.

[Forsakn Wrath]

Lucky Star isn't about romance. 'Nuff said.

this is virtually unintelligible when you post pictures of LS with death and destruction

[Droote]

So you dont mind romance or the fact they could be lesbians but you will deny any form of love between any two characters

they are still friends, just they love each other

If any LS character that is present today got in love with any other LS character that is present today, then that would ruin Lucky Star. If a character fall in love and build a relationship with someone outside of the LS cast, then I would accept it.

If they are friends and love each other in a non-platonic way, then they would not be friends anymore, they would be lovers.

[Yoda]

this is virtually unintelligible when you post pictures of LS with death and destruction
That's beside the point. You're trying to start a flamewar, aren't you? Regardless:


That makes no sense. Do you understand what "unintelligible" means? It means what you posted was absolute gibberish. Pictures? I'm sure you understood what those meant, considering your reaction to them. Please, if you want to get your point across, at least make it so people can understand what you're trying to say.
Why can't we post sad pictures? There was more than enough warning for you. Nobody ever forced you to open those pictures. Either ignore them or grow a pair.

EDIT: To avoid getting off topic, I agree with Droote. Do you honestly think Lucky Star would benefit from such a decision? The show/comic would be radically different.

And unless you're willing to type coherently, Forsakn Wrath, don't bother replying to this post.

[Forsakn Wrath]

Regardless:


That makes no sense. Do you understand what "unintelligible" means? It means what you posted was absolute gibberish. Pictures? I'm sure you understood what those meant, considering your reaction to them. Please, if you want to get your point across, at least make it so people can understand what you're trying to say.
Why can't we post sad pictures? There was more than enough warning for you. Nobody ever forced you to open those pictures. Either ignore them or grow a pair.

EDIT: To avoid getting off topic, I agree with Droote. Do you honestly think Lucky Star would benefit from such a decision? The show/comic would be radically different.


first of all yes is would benefit and the poll can prove of that

secondly i was making a point to your post about LS not having romance but you enjoy dark and sad pictures which is also something lucky star is not and though you did give warning people will still look.

and thirdly all i want is to know why droote would accept them being with anyone else but each other

you think these two being together is the greatest sin of all time. you'll allow spin offs of them playing as MMO characters, murder cases, and even being shrunken in size but the idea of konata and kagami loving one other just makes your stomach turn

[Yoda]

first of all yes is would benefit and the poll can prove of that

Or in other words, argumentum ad populum. My point still stands - making it yuri would completely change the series. It's a four-panel comic strip. A romantic relationship of any kind would defeat the point.

secondly i was making a point to your post about LS not having romance but you enjoy dark and sad pictures which is also something lucky star is not and though you did give warning people will still look.
Quite beside the point. I have nothing against Konata X Kagami in fanon, but in canon, I do. Same goes for the dark pictures. I'd object if they actually did that, perhaps even more than if they turned LS into shoujo-ai.

and thirdly all i want is to know why droote would accept them being with anyone else but each other
you think these two being together is the greatest sin of all time. you'll allow spin offs of them playing as MMO characters, murder cases, and even being shrunken in size but the idea of konata and kagami loving one other just makes your stomach turnI can't speak for Droote, so he'll have to reply to this one. However, it seems like you're making assumptions. Again.

And for the somebody's sake, please type properly next time. Like, at least stop making all those run-on sentences. I don't mean to sound like a grammar Nazi, but it's hard to take you seriously (not to mention a pain to read).

[Forsakn Wrath]

making it yuri would completely change the series. It's a four-panel comic strip. A romantic relationship of any kind would defeat the point.

However, it seems like you're making assumptions. Again.

And for the somebody's sake, please type properly next time. Like, at least stop making all those run-on sentences. I don't mean to sound like a grammar Nazi, but it's hard to take you seriously (not to mention a pain to read).

im not making assumptions, if anything, its an over exaggeration.

yea it would change the series and for the better and it wouldnt defeat the point just because its a four-panel comic strip
some of those carry on to other four-panel strips so the only real limit is pages

this isn't english class so ill type the way that makes me feel most comfortable

[Yoda]

im not making assumptions, if anything, its an over exaggeration.

yea it would change the series and for the better and it wouldnt defeat the point just because its a four-panel comic strip
some of those carry on to other four-panel strips so the only real limit is pages

this isn't english class so ill type the way that makes me feel most comfortable

http://massmultiverse.files.wordpress.com/2010/04/facepalm.jpg
Yeah... no.

[Dally]

I'd think it might turn LS into a more character development kind of manga/anime as Kagami and Konata would have to develop in their relationship brainwise....if you know what I mean.

[Forsakn Wrath]

I'd think it might turn LS into a more character development kind of manga/anime as Kagami and Konata would have to develop in their relationship brainwise....if you know what I mean.

Thank You!!

[Droote]

first of all yes is would benefit and the poll can prove of that

secondly i was making a point to your post about LS not having romance but you enjoy dark and sad pictures which is also something lucky star is not and though you did give warning people will still look.


KonataXKagami is not canon, and like Theodore said, those sad pictures of Konata being bullied or killed aren't canon either. It would really blow if Lucky Star got to that point where Konata were violently bullied or even killed. I understand that some enjoy KonataXKagami and that some enjoy dark LS pics/fanfics, but I don't think most people would be happy about those things getting official and canon.


and thirdly all i want is to know why droote would accept them being with anyone else but each other

you think these two being together is the greatest sin of all time. you'll allow spin offs of them playing as MMO characters, murder cases, and even being shrunken in size but the idea of konata and kagami loving one other just makes your stomach turn

I wouldn't immediately accept anyone getting a romantic relationship with someone out of the blue. I may accept it, whether I liked it or not, that someone got a reasonable romantic relationship that made sense and wasn't done because of peer pressure. One already present character getting romantically involved with another already character would make no sense and would turn the franchise completely. Both Konata and Kagami have both stated that they like males. If they suddenly became lesbian, it would be ludicrous.

I like Lucky Star because it is Lucky Star.

And those spin-offs are official but not Canon. Yoshimizu had little to nothing to do with the OVA.

And please write proper English. Sometimes I plainly can't understand what you are trying to say.

[Forsakn Wrath]

I wouldn't immediately accept anyone getting a romantic relationship with someone out of the blue. I may accept it, whether I liked it or not, that someone got a reasonable romantic relationship that made sense and wasn't done because of peer pressure. One already present character getting romantically involved with another already character would make no sense and would turn the franchise completely. Both Konata and Kagami have both stated that they like males. If they suddenly became lesbian, it would be ludicrous.


so would you accept a spin off by Yoshimizu that slowly had konata x kagami starting a relationship?

and im not including the OVA, though that scene is hilarious

[Droote]

so would you accept a spin off by Yoshimizu that slowly had konata x kagami starting a relationship?

and im not including the OVA, though that scene is hilarious

No. One of the main aspects with Lucky Star is that Konata and Kagami are friends and nothing more. If you changed that, then Lucky Star wouldn't be Lucky Star.

[furball]

No. One of the main aspects with Lucky Star is that Konata and Kagami are friends and nothing more. If you changed that, then Lucky Star wouldn't be Lucky Star.

http://img61.imageshack.us/img61/5448/almostkisszz8.jpg
what's wrong with yuri star?

[Forsakn Wrath]

whats so wrong with change?

having some character development and yuri could spark a whole line of adventure
and experiments ;)

[Yoda]

whats so wrong with change?


Answer:

having some character development and yuri could spark a whole line of adventure
and experiments ;)
Congratulations, Lucky Star is now different in all but name. Again, that's not what LS is about.

[Forsakn Wrath]

Answer:

Congratulations, Lucky Star is now different in all but name. Again, that's not what LS is about.

why cant LS have change?

why dont you think LS could be what it is and more?

[Yoda]

why cant LS have change?

why dont you think LS could be what it is and more?
Stop it with your red herrings. Not only do you consistently try to change the topic, but you rehash your old arguments ad infinitum.

Back on topic. Lucky Star is a slice-of-life comedy (in the same vein as Seinfeld). Add romance, a plot, and/or character development of any kind and it's a whole different animal. And Lucky Star's popularity depends on that fact. Konami tease is merely fanservice.

[Droote]

Answer:

Congratulations, Lucky Star is now different in all but name. Again, that's not what LS is about.

This.

[Forsakn Wrath]

Stop it with your red herrings. Not only do you consistently try to change the topic, but you rehash your old arguments ad infinitum.


its my thread if i want to go off topic i will

you dont like the argument then stop arguing with me

[Yoda]

its my thread if i want to go off topic i will

Lmao. I absolutely love how you fail to address any of my points and immediately get defensive.

Clearly, you don't understand what a red herring (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignoratio_elenchi) is.

you dont like the argument then stop arguing with me
http://knowyourmeme.com/i/000/055/404/original/1265344625026.jpg?1276904829

[VK-Skelton]

Back on topic. Lucky Star is a slice-of-life comedy (in the same vein as Seinfeld). Add romance, a plot, and/or character development of any kind and it's a whole different animal. And Lucky Star's popularity depends on that fact. Konami tease is merely fanservice.

I agree with this, Lucky Star's light, relaxing content was what made it Lucky Star. To include anything stronger would make it an entirely different beast, and I don't know if I'd like that.

[Forsakn Wrath]

I agree with this, Lucky Star's light, relaxing content was what made it Lucky Star. To include anything stronger would make it an entirely different beast, and I don't know if I'd like that.

Lucky Star can still have light, relaxing content with a KonataxKagami

[Lyricalias]

Come on, do you really have to resort to "U MAD", The?

[Droote]

Lucky Star can still have light, relaxing content with a KonataxKagami

If Yoshimizu were to have Konata and Kagami as a couple then one of these two things would be bound to happen:

A) LS would have to confront the seriousness and tenderness a love relationship has, and the whole atmosphere would completely change.

or

B) LS would keep the light-hearted atmosphere and content, but the romantic relationship would appear shallow and superficial. It wouldn't be funny, nor would it be serious and realistic. It would be plain stupid.

[Yoda]

Come on, do you really have to resort to "U MAD", The?
Not really, but with his attitude, it seemed fitting.

[Forsakn Wrath]

Not really, but with his attitude, it seemed fitting.

no, i wasnt mad. stressed maybe
but im done with this argument or atleast you. the past replys you sent have been nothing more then insults and what lucky star is. It seems your more entertained at dodge my questions instead of just answering them

Droote you have given me perfectly reasonable answers and been very compliant and I thank you for that

[Yoda]

no, i wasnt mad. stressed maybe
but im done with this argument or atleast you. the past replys you sent have been nothing more then insults and what lucky star is. It seems your more entertained at dodge my questions instead of just answering them

Droote you have given me perfectly reasonable answers and been very compliant and I thank you for that
Look who's talking :)

And those are insults? Lolwut.

EDIT: However, you shouldn't expect to be treated with respect if you can't respect others in the first place with your attitude and whatnot.

[Forsakn Wrath]

Look who's talking :)

And those are insults? Lolwut.

EDIT: However, you shouldn't expect to be treated with respect if you can't respect others in the first place with your attitude and whatnot.

posting pics like been doing then yes

i respect nearly everyone on this website. my attitude has nothing to do with it.
besides your the one assuming im angry, when ive been completely calm with the post and my replies

its funny when you think you know anything about respect

[DevaPain026]

if it is real I am going to watching every new Lucky Star episode 100 times and reading the chapters only 3 times 'cuz they are big
________
Uggs (http://uggstoreshop.com/)

[Kandako]

Lucky star is not romance.It's a slice of life comedy.
There need be no official relationships.
So if this happened,Lucky Star would be pretty dead to me.

[Z008MJ]

While i would indeed love it in itself, i don't think i could accept it as a part of the actual franchise, like others have said. Making that canon would, even if it were perfectly done, still feel forced. And i believe everone here knows that, if it does not feel natural, it will lose a lot of immersion.

That said, i would really not mind a non-canon spin-off with a subtitle to differ them, involving this theme.

Edit: Or maybe i would mind that, i dunno.

[Inikalord]

This is why we have Fan Fiction and Fan Art. it aint official but atleast there is support for it.

On a serious note though, mmmm I wouldnt feel all that different.

[Mihama Chiyo]

It wouldn't work, and there'd be no Lucky Star forums.

[Vossago]

I didn't want to exaggerate my reaction too much, but then I thought... Yeah, Lucky Star would be dead to me.

I could see Hiyori turning out that way, but not really any other character.

[ifhgsfj]

I'd dislike it, but I wouldn't be all OMG THIS SHOW SUCKS NOW

[Vic]

That said, i would really not mind a non-canon spin-off with a subtitle to differ them, involving this theme.

It would be cool if there was parallel L*S series like Murder Mystery and PS2 Festival and Pocket Travellers was since they didn't seem to bother Y. Kagami about not being canon. I would love having different flavors of L*S running the same time!